Last week, I received an e-mail from my friend and fellow photographer Tom Robbins, which included a suggestion for a future blog topic: seeing in the field. It’s a subject that is simultaneously rich with opportunity and fraught with peril. The opportunity part of the equation is obvious; once you get past the technical part of the puzzle, seeing is really what photography is all about. But the potential pitfalls of the subject are equally evident; how do you go about detailing, via the written word, a cognitively sprawling process that is not only endemic, inherently subjective (to at least a significant degree), deeply personal and visual? It’s a knotty problem.
So, in response to his suggestion, I did what any self-respecting blogger would do when faced with a similar conundrum: I co-opted Tom and asked him to collaborate with me on what I hope will be a numerically unspecified series of installments on the topic of “seeing in the field,” in real time. The entire enterprise remains very much a work in progress–and it may never be anything more than that; we’ll have to see. But hopefully we’ll touch upon such issues as recognizing a worthwhile scene; identifying appealing elements and themes; similarities and differences that arise between the advanced “visualization” of a scene and simply stumbling across something unexpected but worthwhile; fine-tuning composition; and probably a number of other subjects that haven’t even come to mind yet.
Hopefully readers will find all of this of some value. When I was in the process of really getting serious about landscape photography, about 15 years ago, I spent a lot of time thinking about these very topics (or this broader, holistic subject), and read a number of books on the subject of making landscape images. Virtually all of the sources I consulted engaged in a kind of subtle, nuanced interplay between addressing the matter in a tangible, concrete manner and in a more ethereal, intangible way. It was as though there was a kind of intellectual minuet that was being danced.
It remains to be seen how the subject will be treated here, but part of the reason that I wanted to engage Tom in the process was to lessen–if not eliminate–the concern I had that if I dealt with the subject entirely on my own I might end up doing nothing more than giving readers a look at an entirely subjective, non-transferable view. Doing so would, surely, do more harm than good to anyone attempting to practically apply thoughts and procedures lacking in any ability to be extended. By including the thinking of another photographer–one whose interests and approach intersect but don’t entirely overlap my own–I thought a baby step toward consensus on something that might resemble the earliest steps on a 1000-mile journey might be vaguely identifiable.
In any event, this prologue is intended to simply provide fair warning of at least part of what’s in store on this blog in the relatively near future. We hope you find it useful in both a practical and creatively stimulating sense.
Visually stunning photographs!
By: jeandorais on August 15, 2013
at 12:53 pm
Thanks very much.
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 11:37 am
Any tips that you could offer would be very much appreciated! I know that I’ll never have your skills, but I know that I could do better than what I have been doing lately. I’m so out of practice on landscapes that it has been like starting over again.
By: quietsolopursuits on August 15, 2013
at 2:02 pm
I hope that some part of what we cover will be of at least minimal help to you.
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 11:38 am
Hi:
I am looking forward to your future blog with Tom Robbins; however, I am curious as to what Landscape Photography books you found most useful.
Thanks.
Gene
By: Grochowski, Eugene on August 15, 2013
at 3:49 pm
Hi Gene, thanks for weighing in.
The two books I referred to most frequently were How to Photograph Landscapes by Joseph K. Lange and The Making of Landscape Photographs by Charlie Waite.
The Lange book is really a catchall, and covers plenty of technical material as well as aesthetics and composition, but I still found it quite worthwhile when I was just starting out. The Waite book is a bit more esoteric in its approach, but I found it extremely instructive. I do recommend both books for anyone really interested in landscape photography who is in the beginner or intermediate stages of development.
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 11:56 am
Looking forward to your coming words, and love Sunrise, Bear Rocks Preserve beautiful capture of complimentary colours.
By: leecleland on August 15, 2013
at 6:22 pm
Thanks!
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 11:57 am
I’m likewise looking forward to your insight into these issues. I find shooting in the area we do is somewhat challenging to find pleasing compositions. We don’t just have many point-and-shoot vistas. So finding the subtle beauty takes a much keener eye (in my opinion). Always nice to see someone else’s thoughts and ideas in practice to enable some self-reflection and comparison of your own styles and routines.
By: Derek Yow on August 16, 2013
at 3:23 pm
Thanks, Derek. I completely agree with you re the relative difficulty of photographing landscapes in places like northern and central Illinois. I kicked the tires on this subject in the spring of last year: https://lightscapesphotography.wordpress.com/2012/04/26/the-other-midwest/
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 12:12 pm
Great idea, Kerry! I look forward to this collaboration – I’m always fascinated by the interplay of craft and creativity, regardless of art form.
By: composerinthegarden on August 17, 2013
at 1:41 pm
Thanks, Lynn. Hopefully it will turn out to be worth everyone’s while. 🙂
By: kerryl29 on August 17, 2013
at 2:03 pm
Look forward to this series. I think it is a good idea to enlist the help of the person who suggests the topic-the ensuing findings work out for the good of all who are interested.
By: janechese on August 18, 2013
at 12:26 pm
Thanks, Jane. Hopefully this will turn out to be helpful.
By: kerryl29 on August 18, 2013
at 11:28 pm
That initial shot is my favourite, even though it reminds me that Autumn is on the way. Looking forward to seeing what you come up with. 🙂
By: restlessjo on August 21, 2013
at 2:09 am
Thanks very much!
By: kerryl29 on August 21, 2013
at 9:56 pm
I especially like the close up of the rocks and the black & white picture
By: Irene Tobias Rodriguez on August 21, 2013
at 8:25 am
Thank you!
By: kerryl29 on August 21, 2013
at 9:57 pm
Beautiful images! I’m most fond of the B&W, but I’m most impressed by the first. I’ve tried that sort of image many times, but never have been satisfied with the results… It’s deceptively hard to make compositions like that feel both intimate and complete. You did it well!
By: Matt Tilghman on August 21, 2013
at 10:36 am
Thanks, Matt.
By: kerryl29 on August 21, 2013
at 9:57 pm
[…] any entry, posted about two months ago, I provided an introduction to a series of collaborative exchanges planned between myself and my […]
By: Seeing in the Field, Part I | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on October 16, 2013
at 9:24 am
[…] introduction to this series of collaborative entries was posted in mid-August; the initial series post, where Tom’s image […]
By: Seeing in the Field, Part II | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on October 28, 2013
at 9:19 am
[…] introduction to the series is here and Part I and Part II can be read via the corresponding […]
By: Seeing in the Field, Part III | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on November 11, 2013
at 10:01 am
[…] introduction to the series is here and Part I , Part II and Part III can be read via the corresponding […]
By: Seeing in the Field Part IV | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on April 7, 2014
at 10:16 am
[…] is my firm and stated belief that photography is principally about seeing. I think it’s critically important to explore a scene organically–that is, at first, […]
By: The Zoom Crutch | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on October 15, 2019
at 9:18 am
[…] actually taken a stab at attempting to suggest some actionable steps for both of these processes in the past; exactly how much positive impact they’ve had is open to debate. This is the case, […]
By: The Vision Thing | Lightscapes Nature Photography Blog on January 17, 2023
at 8:18 am